Positives The book is widely praised as an exceptionally user-friendly, informative, and comprehensive resource for clinicians and individuals alike. Reviewers highlight its excellent interventions, particularly those focused on grounding and coping skills, which are described as well-written and effective. Many appreciate its pragmatic and compassionate approach to addressing the complex co-morbidity of trauma and substance use, noting its success in dispelling common myths in the field, such as the idea that these issues must be treated independently. Its adaptability for both individual and group therapy sessions, its stand-alone nature, and its applicability to diverse populations, including teen girls in correctional facilities, are frequently mentioned benefits. The inclusion of inspiring quotes, patient anecdotes, and external resource information further enhances its value as a practical guide.
Negatives Despite its many strengths, some reviewers point out areas for improvement. The most significant criticism is that the book has not been updated since 2002, leading to concerns that parts of the content may be outdated in light of recent advances in trauma-informed care. Another consistent suggestion is the desire for the handouts and resources to be made available online or in PDF format for purchasers, enhancing convenience and accessibility. One reviewer also noted that while "problem cases" are listed at the end of chapters, there is no accompanying discussion on how to effectively address them, which could leave some users wanting more guidance.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered an excellent and foundational therapy manual, highly recommended for its well-thought-out approach to integrating trauma and substance use treatment. It is particularly suited for mental health therapists, clinicians, and interns working in the substance abuse field or with clients experiencing trauma, offering a clear and adaptable framework. While primarily intended for professionals, individuals seeking self-help resources for developing coping skills, grounding, and self-compassion may also find parts of the book beneficial, even if their issues do not directly involve substance abuse or PTSD. Despite its age, it remains a highly relevant and impactful resource for those dedicated to helping clients navigate these challenging conditions.
