Positives Reviewers frequently praise the book for its unique and imaginative take on dark fairytales, often compared to the style of the Brothers Grimm. Many found the prose to be lush, lyrical, and rich in detail, creating a distinct and atmospheric reading experience. The concept of fairytales coming to life, especially the occasional snippets from the fictional "Tales from the Hinterland" within the story, was widely enjoyed and considered a highlight, with some wishing for a full collection of these tales. Readers appreciated the book's originality and unpredictability, finding it a captivating and fast-paced read that kept them engaged. The intricate world-building garnered positive remarks for its depth and realism, even within its fantastical elements, and some noted the refreshing lack of a central romance.
Negatives However, the book also drew significant criticism, particularly concerning its main character, Alice. Many reviewers found her to be unlikeable, describing her as rude, ill-tempered, self-centered, and often hypocritical, making it difficult to connect with her perspective. A recurring concern was the problematic treatment of the biracial character, Finch, including perceived dismissiveness of his experiences with racial profiling and frequent negative remarks about his appearance. The pacing of the story was a point of contention, with several readers finding the first half to be slow and more akin to a contemporary or urban fantasy, only introducing significant fantastical elements much later than expected given the marketing. Some also found the writing style to occasionally veer into nonsensical or overly whimsical territory, and the plot in the latter half was described by some as muddled, absurd, or lacking clear resolution, with inconsistent world-building. Other minor criticisms included perceived romanticization of kidnapping and the inclusion of various content warnings.
Conclusion Ultimately, this is a polarizing book that readers tend to either love or strongly dislike. It is best suited for those who enjoy dark, creepy fairytales and are drawn to lyrical, atmospheric prose that prioritizes mood over straightforward plot. Readers who appreciate unique, imaginative concepts and are open to less conventional narratives, even if they feature unlikeable protagonists or minimal romantic subplots, may find themselves engrossed. However, those who prefer clear, consistent plots, well-developed and likable characters, or immediate immersion into a high fantasy setting might find themselves disappointed. Its distinct style and divisive elements mean it will resonate strongly with a specific audience, while others may struggle to engage with its particular blend of mystery and fantasy.
