Positives The book is widely praised as a comprehensive and well-assembled introduction to the "nonhuman turn" in critical theory and philosophy. It offers a rich and varied collection of intellectual perspectives, exploring emergent debates around concepts like Object Oriented Ontology, speculative realism, and new materialism. Reviewers highlight several standout essays for their engaging insights, intellectual fun, and thought-provoking questions, particularly regarding the application of philosophical thought to non-humanity, computational influences on decisions, and the overturning of anthropocentrism. The volume is seen as providing a good sense of an emerging critical discourse, presenting a constellation of viewpoints that, despite potential rivalries, yield fruitful positions for examination.
Negatives A recurring criticism is the book's density and the assumption of a pre-existing working knowledge of complex philosophical concepts, especially Object Oriented Ontology. Some essays are described as challenging, full of jargon, or even "bizarre," making for a difficult reading experience for those not already steeped in the subject matter. Reviewers note that, like many collections, the quality and accessibility of chapters can vary, with some being easier to comprehend than others. A few essays are also criticized for verbosity, taking multiple pages to convey ideas that could be expressed more concisely, and for not fully demystifying the core philosophical concepts for the uninitiated.
Conclusion Despite its challenges, the book is considered an important and worthwhile read for those interested in contemporary critical theory and philosophy, particularly the expanding field of nonhuman studies. It serves as an excellent entry point for readers actively seeking to engage with debates surrounding anthropocentrism and the role of non-human entities in philosophical thought. While it may prove demanding for readers without a background in these specific philosophical movements, those willing to invest the effort will find a stimulating collection that offers significant insight into an evolving and vital area of academic discourse.
