When He Was Wicked

Reviewers widely praise this book for its deeply emotional and mature narrative, setting it apart from other titles in the series. The hero, Michael Stirling, is consistently highlighted as a standout character, described as loyal, caring, devoted, and a "tortured soul." His years of unrequited love and silent pining for the heroine are frequently lauded as heart-wrenching and compelling, making him a favorite hero for many. The author's writing style is commended for its eloquence and ability to evoke strong emotions, effectively portraying themes of grief, loss, and the complex journey of moving on. Readers particularly enjoyed the intense slow burn and high sexual tension between the main characters, with many finding the intimate scenes passionate and the overall romance deeply affecting. The audiobook narration also received specific acclaim for bringing the story to life.

Despite its strengths, the book also drew criticism, primarily concerning the heroine, Francesca. Many reviewers found her indecisive, wishy-washy, and at times frustrating, feeling that her reluctance to acknowledge her developing feelings for the hero dragged on for too long. Some felt her guilt over past events was overemphasized, leading to a prolonged and occasionally depressing tone. The pacing was sometimes described as drawn out, with certain plot points feeling forced. Additionally, some readers felt that the hero's "rake" persona was not consistently portrayed, and his initial actions in response to challenging circumstances were seen as cowardly. A common point of contention was the ending, which several reviewers found abrupt and unsatisfying, leaving them wanting more resolution for the characters' journey. Some also noted a reduced presence of the beloved Bridgerton family dynamics compared to other books in the series.

Overall, this book offers a polarizing yet often intense reading experience, with many considering it among the best in the series for its emotional depth and character development, while others found its narrative choices frustrating. It is particularly recommended for readers who enjoy historical romances featuring emotionally tortured heroes, profound unrequited love, and stories that explore the complexities of love after loss. Those who appreciate a slow-burn romance with significant angst, heartfelt devotion, and passionate intimate scenes are likely to be captivated. However, readers who prefer faster-paced narratives, decisive heroines, or a stronger focus on ensemble family interactions might find aspects of this story less engaging.