خواب آشفتۀ نفت از قرارداد دارسى تا سقوط رضا شاه

This multi-volume work is widely praised for its comprehensive and detailed exploration of Iran's oil history, covering a significant historical period from the early concessions through to later pivotal events. Reviewers consistently highlight its extensive documentation, emphasizing that the book is meticulously researched and based on a rich array of sources, including Iranian, English, and American perspectives. It is considered an excellent reference work, offering profound insights into the complex struggles of Iranian statesmen over oil rights and the long-term consequences of these negotiations. The book is also lauded for its high publication quality and its ability to offer fresh perspectives on historical figures and events, stimulating critical thought about oil's profound impact on Iran's political and economic landscape.

Despite its strengths, the book presents several challenges for readers. Many reviewers found it dense and difficult to read, citing its considerable length and occasional repetitiveness in presenting issues and quotes. A prominent criticism revolves around the author's perceived strong bias, particularly an inclination towards the theory of foreign manipulation in Iranian affairs. Some readers felt that the author's interpretations or theories were at times not fully supported by, or even contradicted by, the very sources he cited, leading to questions about the book's objectivity. The author's use of strong judgments and emotionally charged language in certain analyses was also noted as a potential drawback. Additionally, the high price of the physical publication was mentioned by some reviewers.

Overall, "The Troubled Dream of Oil" stands as a monumental and essential contribution to understanding the critical role of oil in shaping Iran's modern history and its intricate relations with global powers. It is highly recommended for serious students of Iranian history, researchers, and anyone seeking a deeply documented and exhaustive account of the nation's oil saga. This book will particularly appeal to readers who appreciate comprehensive historical analyses, are prepared for a challenging and lengthy read, and are willing to critically engage with an author's distinct interpretations. However, those seeking a purely neutral, concise, or easily digestible overview might find it less suitable.