نگارش و ويرايش

The book receives commendation for its sections on editing, which are consistently described as very good to excellent. Reviewers highlight that these parts are particularly effective in sensitizing readers to the structure of sentences and words, offering valuable insights. It is also noted that the book contains useful content, and despite some drawbacks, readers will eventually discover beneficial information within its pages, making it a suitable starting point for those beginning their studies in editing.

However, a significant portion of the book, specifically the writing sections, draws considerable criticism. These parts are often labeled as overly verbose, containing too much talk, and are considered largely unhelpful or practically useless by reviewers. It is suggested that a substantial amount of the book, possibly half, consists of less valuable material, with some estimating only about one hundred pages to be truly useful. There are also concerns about the book's originality, with one review questioning if it is derivative of other existing writing and editing books, leading to the overall impression that it is not particularly remarkable.

In conclusion, this book presents a mixed experience. Its primary strength lies in its well-regarded editing content, which offers a solid foundation for understanding sentence and word structure. However, readers should be aware of the less impactful and potentially redundant writing sections, which necessitate sifting through to find the truly valuable material. This book would be most beneficial for beginners in the field of editing who are seeking an introductory guide, but it may not fully satisfy those looking for a comprehensive or highly original work.