Les plus Many reviewers praise this book for its comprehensive and detailed explanations, making it an excellent resource for those new to C++ programming. It is frequently recommended for students and beginners, offering a clear and step-by-step approach to understanding programming fundamentals. Readers appreciate the abundance of examples and exercises, which are often cited as helpful for solidifying concepts and showcasing the power of C++ and object-oriented programming. The book is also lauded for providing a solid foundation and serving as a valuable reference, with some finding it motivating and inspiring for learning about computer science. It is described as simple, clear, and easy to read, with smart tips and hints throughout.
Les moins However, the book also receives significant criticism. Some reviewers find it disorganized and haphazard in its introduction of topics, arguing that it burdens beginners with unnecessarily complex examples and excessive detail rather than focusing on core concepts. Critics describe it as overwhelmingly verbose and following a 'cookbook' style that explains 'how to' but not always 'why' or 'when.' There are also concerns about its teaching methodology, specifically a perceived flaw where it guides readers down incorrect programming paths before explaining the proper way, which some find counterproductive. While comprehensive for introductory topics, a few readers note that some complicated or advanced concepts could be explored more fully. Additionally, older editions are noted as being dated, and some translations are reported to be confusing and difficult to read.
Conclusion Overall, this book appears to be a polarizing resource, often lauded as an essential guide for absolute beginners and students seeking a thorough introduction to C++ and programming principles. It is particularly well-suited for those who appreciate extensive detail and numerous code examples, and who might use it as a primary text in a structured course or as a comprehensive reference. However, readers who prefer a more streamlined, less verbose approach with a deeper focus on the 'why' behind programming constructs, or those looking for a book that excels in teaching advanced C++ topics, might find it less effective. Potential readers should be aware of the criticisms regarding organization and verbosity, and consider seeking the newest edition for up-to-date content.
