Positives The book is widely praised for its deeply emotional and captivating storytelling, with many readers describing it as a "beautifully written" and "soul-soothing" experience that can evoke strong feelings, from giddy excitement to profound heartbreak. Reviewers frequently highlight the compelling nature of the narrative, noting how easily they became absorbed and found it difficult to put down. A significant draw is the central romance, often characterized as an "under appreciated" blend of childhood best friends to lovers and second-chance tropes, celebrated for its palpable chemistry, angst, and yearning. Characters like Elliot are particularly adored, often described as thoughtful, kind, and devoted, while Macy is found to be relatable. The dual timeline structure, alternating between past and present, is also frequently commended for building anticipation and investing readers in the characters' journey, alongside unique elements like a secret reading closet and shared love for books.
Negatives Despite its strengths, the book receives criticism, primarily concerning the handling of a pivotal plot point later in the story. Many reviewers express disappointment and even anger that a sensitive and traumatic event is not adequately addressed or framed appropriately by the characters or the narrative itself, often feeling brushed over or mislabeled. This aspect significantly impacted the overall rating for several readers, overshadowing earlier enjoyment. Some found the characters, particularly in their adult interactions, to be irritating or to engage in frustrating communication breakdowns, prolonging the central conflict unnecessarily. Additionally, aspects of the teenage romance, such as repetitive descriptions or the perceived maturity of the characters' dialogue and behavior for their age, were not universally appreciated. A few reviewers also felt the pacing could be slow in the initial chapters or that certain subplots were abruptly abandoned.
Conclusion Overall, opinions on the book are somewhat divided, yet many readers find it to be a powerful and satisfying emotional journey despite its perceived flaws. It is often described as a bittersweet yet heartwarming read that excels at portraying grief, first loves, and reconnection. This book would particularly appeal to readers who cherish deeply emotional second-chance romances featuring childhood friends, enjoy a dual timeline narrative, and appreciate stories that evoke strong feelings of longing and angst. However, those who expect a thorough and sensitive exploration of difficult themes, or who are easily frustrated by prolonged character communication issues, might find certain aspects of the book less satisfying.
